top of page
What our customers are saying...
Helping you make the right decision.
Kind words from our clients
Austin George
Aug 24, 2026
The team has always been fantastic at helping with our policies. My recent experience with Tina has been nothing short of amazing. She was patient, knowledgeable and kind throughout the process of several policy changes I needed on short notice. This is the kind of service you only get from hometown agencies and will continue to use them for years to come.
Syd Zim
Jul 26, 2026
Liz is great!
Dave S
Jul 25, 2026
Always prompt and courteous! Would recommend to friends and family.
Jerry Dz
Jul 25, 2026
I've been with Sitter Insurance since Gary started back in the 70's. I have been recommending Sitter Insurance most of my life. I have auto and home insurance.
Bertrand Artigues
Jul 25, 2026
30+ years with them!!!! Nothing else to say!!!!
Teri DiRienzo
Jul 25, 2026
Friendly staff, always helpful.
Laura P
Jul 25, 2026
Sitter Insurance is the best insurance agency! They are always there to answer any questions and are just great people!
Bud Hughes
Jul 25, 2026
Great contacts every time.
Gordon Evans
Jul 25, 2026
Excellent service if they don’t know the answer immediately, they’ll find it for you quickly
Stephanie Williams
Jul 25, 2026
The staff is very I teractive and answers all questions.
Stacey Steen
Jul 17, 2026
The employees at my insurance company have always been easy to work with, professional, helpful and pleasant. Thanks for all you do!
Marietta Stalsky
Jul 17, 2026
Always ready with sound advice.
Deborah Chludzinski
Jul 17, 2026
I’m so happy with my insurance and my agent
They have been with me through all my changes and growth
They have been helpful and supportive throughout the years 💕
Randall Hodges
Jul 15, 2026
I've been with Sitter Insurance for 35 years, great agency with great people.
Debbie Anderson
Jul 15, 2026
Always helpful with questions and or paying our auto insurance by phone.
John Crowley
Jul 15, 2026
Great service!!!
Robert Valencic
Jul 15, 2026
Great customer service
Amber Barber
Jul 15, 2026
The office staff is eager to help. I have insured my vehicles, home and camper through the Agency for many years. The rates that are able to provide through their carriers are matched by the service they provide.
Timothy McNair
Jul 15, 2026
Excellent service and solid knowledge of the products and the customer's needs. Highly recommend.
Mrs. Brown
Jul 15, 2026
Always so polite and easy to deal with
Robert Schulz
Jul 15, 2026
Great service.
R Scott Domowicz
Jul 15, 2026
I love our agent Anna! See is amazing.
Courtney Stoll
Jul 15, 2026
Liz was so helpful in talking through my options prior to renewals and figured out the best options that protect us in the event of a bad day, but also are realistic for us to manage from a price perspective. Quick responses and very easy to work with!
john
Dec 15, 2025
We will look into some life insurance policies for my good friends. We will be in contact JOHN FITZGERALD D. ♤
Mike Anderson
Jul 6, 2025
Great helpful staff and caring.
Frank Singer
Jul 3, 2025
Our insurance company for the 36 years we have been in our home. They have treated us very well.
Julianne Duda
Jul 2, 2025
Everyone at the agency has been great to work with. Anna follows up in any questions I have.
Shelley Torrey
Jun 28, 2025
I was referred to Sitter Insurance by a family member to try to save money on my car and homeowner's insurance. Liz Parry was fantastic in determining my needs for coverages and limits at a price that was literally hundreds less than I was paying at AAA. She is knowledgeable and very pleasant to deal with. I highly recommend Sitter Insurance!,,
Timothy Smith
Jun 27, 2025
Sitter Insurance has always been there for me. In cases for claims, they are quick to respond. I have had them for decades and highly recommend them.
CAS Laptop
Jun 27, 2025
I needed a quote on a homeowners policy quickly for a closing on a property. Anna was both helpful and understanding. 30+ years with Rutkowski insurance and the team always impressed. Thank you!
James Weaver
Jun 26, 2025
Sitter Insurance has done an excellent job insuring our restored sailboat, Lola Jane
David A
Jul 14, 2024
Great agent for a great insurance company. Very helpful and knowledgeable.
Paul Olszewski
Feb 28, 2024
Very good company to get insurance for auto, home, and boat!
Patricia Nagelkirk
Dec 18, 2023
A few years ago, Sitter Insurance provided substantive, timely and reasonably priced commercial insurance coverage when our former provider could not. My partners and I were very pleased! And today? Sitter Insurance continues to be my provider of choice for all personal insurance needs. Any time my husband and I needed support we could get a response same day. Thank you!
Andrew Kiefer
Dec 12, 2023
Liz took the time to figure out how to get me the lowest price, I am very satisfied!
Laurie
Sep 20, 2023
Tony is very knowledgeable and friendly. Feels like we’ve made a friend.
Aleksandr Osmak
Dec 30, 2021
Sitter Insurance is a great team of Insurance agents that know the industry and get you properly insured. They are super competitive and very responsive to all inquiries. I have nothing but the best words to describe these folks. Thank you Tony, Joe , and Liz for your outstanding service! Anyone shopping for insurance make sure to check them out.
Andrew Dick
Apr 1, 2021
Very nice and helpful staff! We highly recommend Sitter Insurance for all insurance needs!
Carolyn Kuhl
Dec 2, 2020
Great availability, communication, and ease of changing agents!!
Pam
Apr 13, 2020
When I moved to PA Tony and his staff helped me with all of my insurance needs. From renters insurance when I have never rented before to auto insurance. I moved from Ohio and so many things are done differently in PA. I have to have y car inspected and get my plates from a notary. Tony walked me through every step. When I moved back to Ohio Tony and his staff again have helped me with every step. They are friendly and knowledgeable.
Fiodar Palkhouski
Aug 14, 2019
(Translated by Google) Cool guys
(Original)
Классные ребята
NaruAvaFan999
Jun 21, 2019
Even though I only had a car insured by Erie Insurance for 7 months, I still had an amazing experience with Mike Figurski. I have 0 knowledge of cars and insurance and such and Mike really made the entire process of signing up for auto insurance so easy. Always professional and courteous, Mike replied to all my questions and concerns in a timely and efficient manner. Thanks again Mike!
bottom of page