Trisha Shallenbarger
Life Insurance Specialist and Medicare Advisor


More About Me
Phone: (814) 835-3889
Email: trisha@sitterinsurance.com
Address: 4267 W Ridge Rd, Erie, PA 16506, USA
For me, insurance has always been about people first. Over the last 10+ years, I’ve had the privilege of sitting down with individuals and families throughout Pennsylvania and Ohio to help them make informed decisions about protecting the people they love most. Those conversations are the part of my work I value most.
I grew up in Millcreek Township in Erie, Pennsylvania, where I still live and work today. After graduating from McDowell Senior High School, I continued my education through classes at both Gannon University and Penn State Behrend. Being deeply connected to this community has helped me build lasting relationships with clients who want guidance they can genuinely trust.
As a Life Insurance Specialist and Medicare/LTC Advisor with Sitter Insurance Agency, I specialize in Life, Health, Medicare, and Long-Term Care planning, while also bringing experience across all personal lines insurance. I’m licensed in Property and Casualty, Life, and Health insurance, and I’m also a Certified Medicare and Long-Term Care Advocate. My goal is never to overwhelm people with insurance terminology. Instead, I focus on education, honest conversations, and helping clients feel confident in the decisions they make for themselves and their families.
Outside the office, I’m usually doing something active, especially when Erie weather cooperates. I enjoy working out, spending time outdoors, and getting lost in a good book whenever I can. I’m also passionate about giving back to the local community. I’ve been involved with Rivalz to End Alz for the past five years, serving as a team captain for the last three while helping raise money for the Alzheimer’s Association in Erie. I’ve also volunteered as a coach with EYSA for the past three years, which has been an incredibly rewarding experience.
Whether someone is planning for the future, navigating Medicare options, or looking to better protect their family, I believe the best insurance experience starts with a real conversation and someone willing to listen.



.png)
